Milkshake Recipe Ideas: What Kind Should You Make?

By BrainFall Staff - Updated: April 30, 2024

There’s simply nothing better than a cold milkshake when you’re craving a dessert that will quench your thirst. Also, there are not many desserts that will quench your thirst, so a milkshake is at the top of the list no matter what. Regardless, having a milkshake gives you the opportunity to enjoy a tasty treat with a meal or as its own meal. There are also a ton of additions you can make with a milkshake recipe to add to your ice cream. Chocolate syrup, whipped cream, caramel sauce, and a Maraschino cherry are just some of what you can add.

If you’re now jonesing for a milkshake, we’ve done our job. We’ve probably got you on your way out to buy chocolate milk or strawberry ice cream. If you’re not sure what kind of milkshake you should make, we’re here to help. Take this quiz and we’ll suggest what milkshake recipe you should try.

Milkshake recipe

Milkshakes are a dessert beverage that combines milk and ice cream. The ice cream and milk are blended together to create a thicker and creamer drink. You can choose all kinds of ice creams or milks to create your milkshake recipe.

If you're making a milkshake, you need ice cream, first and foremost. The second ingredient you need to have is milk. After that, you can pick and choose what else you want. If you're making a vanilla milkshake recipe, you can add things like caramel sauce, vanilla extract, mini chocolate chips, fresh strawberries, and more. If you don't have any milk, you can use malted milk powder.

Milkshake toppings can be blended in or added to the top of the drink. For a richer and creamer milkshake, use full-fat ice cream and whole milk. You can adjust that if you want to save some calories. Whether you're using chocolate ice cream, Rocky Road ice cream, or cookie dough ice cream, it will all work well in a milkshake. Adding whipped cream on top is a must.

Milkshake Recipe Ideas: What Kind Should You Make?

As we all know, nothing beats the heat like a cold, creamy milkshake. Whether you're lounging by the pool or hiding out in the coolest part of the house, a milkshake is our go-to treat when the temperatures soar. With so many flavors to choose from and toppings to sprinkle on, it's no wonder there's a whole world of milkshake recipes just waiting to be explored. We're not talking about your run-of-the-mill vanilla and chocolate shakes here—though they hold a special place in our hearts.

Why settle for the familiar when you can mix things up? Imagine sipping on a decadent Oreo milkshake or tantalizing your taste buds with a strawberry milkshake that screams summer from the first slurp. Want to take a walk on the wild side? How about a piña colada milkshake that brings a bit of the tropics right to your glass, no plane ticket required. Each sip promises a passport to instant refreshment, making even the hottest summer day bearable.

So, our fellow shake enthusiasts, are you ready to learn which milkshake concoction will send your spirits—and taste buds—soaring? Dive into our whirlwind of milkshake recipe ideas, and find out which shake is your soulmate. It's a quiz that's sure to be almost as enjoyable as drinking the milkshake itself—almost. Let's get that blender whirring and shake up some fun!

The Art of Milkshake Crafting

Milkshakes are our creamy canvas, and we’re here to be the Da Vincis of dairy! Let’s dive spoon-first into crafting the ultimate indulgent treat that’ll make your taste buds do the twist.

Choosing Your Creamy Base

The heart of every great milkshake is the ice cream. Vanilla ice cream is classic and malleable, ready to take on any flavors you throw its way. For the dairy-averse, fear not! A delicious dairy-free alternative ensures everyone gets a sip of bliss. Remember, a thick milkshake begins with less liquid; whole milk adds richness but alter the ratio to suit your consistency expectations.

Sweet Synergies: Flavor Combinations

Chocolate lovers, unite! A chocolate milkshake is rich, fudgy, and utterly divine. But if you're a fan of something fruitier, nothing beats the tried-and-true strawberry milkshake—it’s like summer in a glass. Mix and match flavors like a mad scientist until you find your signature concoction.

Milkshake Mix-Ins: From Simple to Outrageous

Now, let's get wild with mix-ins! From the simplicity of crushed cookies to the outrageousness of candied bacon, each addition brings texture and surprise. The rule is – there are no rules! Want to toss in some pickles? Go for it. Our taste buds won't judge (out loud).

The Perfect Blend: Tools and Techniques

A blender is our trusty sidekick, whipping our masterpieces to perfection. No blender? No worries! A food processor, or dare we say, an immersion blender might just do the trick. Combine ingredients with the finesse of a milkshake maestro, pulsing to that just-right thickness. Remember, blend not just for consistency, but for great power – and with great power comes the need to do the dishes.

Accessorizing Your Shake

When we whip up milkshakes, we're not just making a drink—we're crafting an experience. The final flourish comes from how we dress them up. It's like putting on that snazzy bow tie or sparkly earrings before you step out.

Garnishes and Toppings: The Cherry on Top

Whipped Cream: We pile it high, making our shake as fluffy as a happy cloud.
Chocolate Sauce: A generous drizzle turns any shake into a sinfully delicious treat.
Syrup: Whether it’s strawberry, caramel, or butterscotch, we zigzag it over the cream with the precision of a painter.
Cherries: No shake masterpiece is complete without a cherry perched on top.
Sprinkles: These little sugar specks add a pop of color and a dash of whimsy.
Nuts: A sprinkle of crushed nuts gives a satisfying crunch.
Chocolate Chips: For that bonus chocolatey chomp. Because, let’s face it, there's no such thing as too much chocolate.

Garnishes are the exclamation point at the end of our milkshake sentence!

Serving with Style: Glassware and Presentation

Straws: We opt for the big, wide straws—functional and fun for those thick and creamy shakes.
Mason Jars: Picture this: our milkshake served in a chilled mason jar. It screams rustic chic and Instagram-worthy in every sip!

While we’re all about the taste, we know eyes eat first. So we dress our shakes to impress, in glassware that shouts personality and a presentation that begs for a photo op. It's all about serving up a visual feast that makes everyone say, "I need to try that!"

Start Quiz!