Which 90s Heartthrob Is Your Dream Guy?

Was your dream guy popular during that decade when puka shell necklaces, scrunchies and Beanie Babies were all the rage? Which 90s heartthrob is the perfect match for you?

Which 90s Heartthrob Is Your Dream Guy?

The '90s gifted us with scrunchies, neon windbreakers, and a parade of heartthrobs whose posters graced the walls of many a flustered teenager’s bedroom. Now, don't try to play it cool like your heart never raced a beat faster while watching "Titanic" or "10 Things I Hate About You." It's the era that brought you the charming smiles, brooding glares, and those floppy hairdos that, let's admit, you totally dug.

Imagine a time machine where you zoom back to the prime days of '90s crushes. Would you end up with the sharp-jawed rebel or the sweet boy-next-door with the voice of an angel? You've seen them rock the silver screen with their leather jackets and endearing quirks, but which one would call you "the one" between takes?

While DiCaprio might have stolen hearts as Jack Dawson, and Jonathan Taylor Thomas seemed to understand you from the confines of a "Tiger Beat" magazine, perhaps there's another dreamboat out there you’ve overlooked. So, dust off your old mixtapes and get ready to find out which '90s heartthrob would be leaving you those quintessential over-the-top voicemails declaring his undying affection. Because frankly, you're as timeless as the '90s romcoms themselves, and it's high time you'd know which leading man would have been your ultimate prom date.

Decoding the Heartthrob Phenomenon

Strap in, time traveler; we're revving up the DeLorean and heading straight back to a time of frosted tips and oversized flannel: the '90s. Your mission? Understanding the allure of the '90s heartthrob and just why your walls might have been plastered with their dreamy posters.

Defining the '90s Heartthrob

Imagine a concoction of charisma, a dash of boyish charm, and a sprinkle of hair gel—voilà, you've cooked up your quintessential '90s heartthrob. These were the poster boys for teen magazines, the princes of pop culture, and the reason VHS tapes of teen dramas wore out from overuse. Whether it was Leonardo DiCaprio making hearts skip in "Titanic" or Jonathan Taylor Thomas (better known as JTT) giving you "Home Improvement" heart palpitations, each heartthrob had a special recipe for swoon-worthiness.

Icons of an Era

Underneath the luster of '90s heartthrobs like James Van Der Beek—whose furrowed brow could carry an entire scene in "Dawson's Creek"—was more than just a pretty face. They were time capsules of fun and nostalgia. Leonardo DiCaprio wasn't just Jack Dawson; he was the king of the world in your daydreams. And lest we forget Will from "Will & Grace" showcasing a different kind of charm or Paul Rudd, whose ageless wonder makes us question if he really did discover the Fountain of Youth. There was a heartthrob for every type of late-night fantasy. So, who's your '90s dream guy? Maybe it's time to find out and get your groove on with a totally rad quiz that might just awaken your inner teen spirit.

Your Dream Guy Match-Up

Get ready to swoon and sigh as we help you find your perfect '90s heartthrob match. Whether you're seeking a sensitive artist or a bad-boy with a heart of gold, these subsections will guide you to your dreamy blast from the past.

Quiz: Discover Your '90s Crush

Time to break out the tiger beat! Take a charming stroll down memory lane with a quiz designed to pinpoint your '90s crush. Will it be the painterly passion of Leonardo DiCaprio or the sweet serenades of a pop singer that send your heart aflutter? Imagine the click of your mouse is like the flip of a magazine page as you answer questions that tap into your deepest romantic desires.

• Leonardo DiCaprio: The eternal heartthrob from Titanic, will Jack's artistic soul capture your heart?
• Joshua Jackson: Is it Pacey’s wit and charm that’ll have you watching "Dawson's Creek" reruns?
• Andrew Keegan: Or perhaps the brooding looks and smirks of Camp Nowhere’s bad boy?

From On-Screen to In-Dreams

Now, don't just daydream about your '90s crush; converse with your friends about which on-screen beau would make the perfect boyfriend. Was it Heath Ledger with his rebellious allure, or the sports-loving stud Mark-Paul Gosselaar? Wouldn't it be hilarious if your dream guy’s passion for life mirrored your own zest for retro romance?

• Heath Ledger: A knight in shining armor or a poetic soul, which Ledger role makes you swoon?
• Mark-Paul Gosselaar: Let's be real, those golden locks had you at 'time out', didn't they?

Discuss, debate, and laugh over which hunk would have won your teenage heart — all in good fun, of course!